Americans lost hundreds of billions on crypto speculation. Why is only some of it considered gambling?
Americans are on tempo to lose extra money on authorized playing this 12 months than at any level within the nation’s historical past.
A new analysis by economics writer Joseph Politano tasks that the overall will exceed 1 / 4 trillion {dollars} in 2026. Losses have climbed 67% for the reason that begin of COVID-19 and one other 8% over the previous 12 months alone, outpacing any development recorded between 2000 and 2020.
That determine counts only sportsbooks and casinos, and it excludes the cash transferring via prediction markets, crypto buying and selling, and inventory choices, every of which now channels billions of {dollars} a 12 months into exercise that, economically talking, appears to be like an amazing deal like a wager.
The hole between what regulators name playing and what they name investing has turn out to be one of the stranger options of American monetary life.
A resident of a state the place sports activities betting is unlawful can nonetheless open a crypto prediction market app and take a place on whether or not the Federal Reserve cuts charges in September, whether or not a hurricane makes landfall in Florida, or which group wins the World Series.
A dealer with no view on financial fundamentals should purchase an possibility that expires in six hours and is, each in idea and in observe, a wager on which path a inventory index strikes earlier than lunch.
A youngster with a crypto pockets can put money into a token that exists purely as a result of a meme went viral.
Each of these actions entails risking cash on an unsure final result, however every falls underneath a distinct regulator, a distinct authorized customary, and in some circumstances, no significant oversight in any respect.
The scale of the playing drawback
The American Gaming Association reported that business gaming income within the US hit a file $78.72 billion in 2025, up 9.2% from the 12 months earlier than. Sports betting alone generated $16.96 billion in income on a complete deal with of $166.94 billion, a rise of practically 23% in income and 11% in deal with over 2024, when Americans had already wagered slightly below $150 billion legally on sports activities.
Since the Supreme Court’s 2018 ruling in Murphy v. NCAA struck down the federal prohibition on sports activities betting, 39 states and Washington, D.C. have legalized some type of it, and the trade has expanded yearly since.
Politano’s evaluation highlighted the implications of such a rise in playing that prolonged nicely past sportsbooks’ stability sheets. Research cited in his piece discovered that in states the place sports activities betting is authorized, an NFL dwelling group’s upset loss raises the speed of intimate associate violence by ten share factors greater than in states with out authorized betting.
Separate work from New York Fed economists Jacob Goss and Daniel Mangrum, drawing on thousands and thousands of credit score stories, discovered that debt delinquency charges rose as states legalized sports activities playing, with the impact concentrated amongst males and folks underneath 40. You will not see that in AGA’s income figures, which measure the trade’s development with out capturing the toll it takes on the households funding it.
At the identical time, a set of markets that regulators do not classify as playing in any respect has grown even quicker in share phrases.
Prediction market exercise additionally surged. Data compiled by Gambling Insider put 2025 notional buying and selling quantity throughout main prediction market platforms at greater than $44 billion, with Polymarket and Kalshi collectively accounting for roughly $38 billion to $39 billion of that complete. Polymarket accounted for about $21.5 billion, and Kalshi for $17.1 billion, between January and November 2025.
Options markets and crypto additionally noticed elevated retail participation in short-horizon hypothesis. Total US listed choices quantity topped 15.2 billion contracts in 2025, a sixth consecutive annual file and a 26% bounce over 2024, based on Cboe’s year-end report.
Zero-days-to-expiration contracts on the S&P 500, choices which can be opened and closed inside a single day, averaged 2.3 million contracts a day and made up 59% of complete SPX quantity, with retail merchants accountable for roughly half to 60% of that move.
In crypto, memecoins fell 61% from their early-2025 highs to about $36.5 billion earlier than recovering to roughly $47.3 billion in early 2026. CryptoSlate’s personal year-end accounting of 2025’s worst-performing tokens traced that spherical journey via a string of movie star and politically themed launches that left early insiders enriched and late retail patrons underwater.
What makes this assortment of actions value inspecting collectively, slightly than as separate industries, is that the underlying financial conduct is typically equivalent whereas the authorized therapy is not.
| Activity | Regulator | Legal classification |
|---|---|---|
| Sports betting | State gaming commissions | Gambling |
| Prediction markets | CFTC (Kalshi, Polymarket US) | Financial derivatives |
| Stock choices | SEC / CFTC | Investing |
| Crypto derivatives | CFTC | Commodity derivatives |
| Memecoins | Largely unregulated | Digital belongings |
A dealer who buys a contract on whether or not the Fed cuts charges in September and a dealer who buys an out-of-the-money possibility tied to the identical Fed choice are each utilizing federally regulated market infrastructure to specific a short-horizon view.
The sharper distinction is with sportsbook-style event wagers: sports activities bets routed via licensed books face state playing guidelines, whereas related occasion publicity routed via federally regulated prediction markets is being litigated underneath derivatives legislation, with out the identical state licensing, tax assortment, or responsible-gambling necessities.
This is the fault line the playing trade has begun combating over. AGA estimates that prediction markets providing sports-related contracts have diverted greater than $500 million in potential state and tribal betting tax income for the reason that begin of 2025.
The battle has already produced a tangle of lawsuits and state enforcement actions in Nevada, Massachusetts, Arizona, and Tennessee, all testing whether or not federal derivatives legislation preempts state playing statutes.
The CFTC itself is break up on the query alongside generational traces: former Chairman Gary Gensler filed a short in June siding with AGA and arguing that Congress by no means meant his personal company to turn out to be a nationwide sports-betting regulator, whereas the present CFTC has sued states directly to say unique jurisdiction over the identical contracts.
The dispute has break up the playing trade itself. DraftKings and FanDuel both resigned from the AGA in November 2025, days earlier than DraftKings launched its personal federally regulated event-contract product, after the commerce group moved to bar members that function prediction markets.
Within six months, that product had reached a $3.1 billion annualized trading run rate, a fraction of Kalshi’s scale however proof that the state-licensed sportsbook trade now sees extra upside within the federal derivatives lane than within the framework it spent a decade constructing.
Why regulation nonetheless relies upon on class, not threat
The present regulatory framework nonetheless relies upon on authorized classes constructed for various markets: securities legislation for securities and choices on them, commodities legislation for futures and occasion contracts, and state playing legislation for wagers.
The drawback is that newer merchandise and retail buying and selling conduct now blur the sensible line between these classes. A same-day possibility, a sports activities contract on a prediction market, and a short-lived memecoin commerce can expose customers to related loss patterns whereas triggering very totally different safeguards.
This produces outcomes which can be troublesome to justify on any grounds aside from historic accident. Depending on platform entry and ongoing litigation, a resident of a state with out authorized sports activities betting might be able to commerce sports-linked occasion contracts via a federally regulated prediction market with fewer sportsbook-specific restrictions than apply to licensed books in states the place betting is authorized.
A retail dealer can lose a paycheck on a same-day possibility with the identical pace and finality as a shedding parlay, however the loss is recorded as an funding final result slightly than a playing one, exempting it from the responsible-gambling infrastructure states have spent years constructing.
Meanwhile, a memecoin with no underlying enterprise might keep away from significant federal oversight except its launch, promotion, or sale creates securities-law publicity, leaving a big speculative market exterior the sort of purpose-built consumer-protection regime utilized to playing.
Economists and playing researchers who research these overlapping markets are inclined to argue that regulation ought to monitor the danger a product really poses, elements like leverage, time horizon, dependancy potential, and the chance of catastrophic loss, slightly than which authorized bucket a product occurs to fall into.
Under that framework, a same-day choices contract and a same-day sports activities wager would face related scrutiny regardless of which regulator indicators off on them, and a memecoin with 99% odds of shedding most of its worth inside two months wouldn’t escape oversight just because it’s denominated in stablecoins slightly than {dollars}.
None of this implies each greenback routed via prediction markets, choices, or crypto tokens represents disguised playing, and lots of the exercise in every class displays real hedging, value discovery, or long-term funding.
But the nation has constructed an elaborate authorized structure that treats equivalent financial conduct in a different way relying on which door an individual walks via to put it, taxing and regulating a sports activities wager made via a sportsbook much more closely than the identical wager made via a federally sanctioned trade, whereas leaving a whole class of speculative crypto belongings virtually untouched.
Americans are shedding a historic quantity of cash throughout all of these channels concurrently, and the regulatory system meant to guard them was constructed for a model of finance that not exists.
The publish Americans lost hundreds of billions on crypto speculation. Why is only some of it considered gambling? appeared first on CryptoSlate.
