Arthur Hayes’ Maelstrom Exec Exposes 44% Loss in Top Crypto VC Bet Even as BTC Doubles
A senior director at Arthur Hayes’ Maelstrom funding agency revealed {that a} $100,000 funding in a crypto enterprise capital fund had fallen to $56,000 over 4 years.
This decline occurred regardless of Bitcoin doubling in worth and seed-stage tokens rising by as much as 75 instances over the identical interval.
Fund Underperformance Sparks Transparency Debate
The revelation, made by Akshat, Maelstrom’s funding director, has intensified scrutiny of crypto VC fund efficiency and price constructions.
Akshat shared his expertise as a restricted accomplice in an early-stage token fund. His funding from 4 years in the past has misplaced 44% of its worth, regardless of the continuing bull marketplace for digital belongings. Akshat reported that the fund charged 3% annual administration charges and 30% efficiency charges (carry).
He compared the fund’s results to benchmarks. Over the course of four years, Bitcoin’s value doubled, and seed deals delivered returns ranging from 20 to 75 times the initial investment.
Akshat described this outcome as significant underperformance, attributing it to the growth of large venture funds chasing a limited set of successful projects in the crypto sector.
The post featured a capital account statement dated September 2025, which showed an opening balance of $54,287.84 and an ending balance of $56,054.01. The year-to-date net rate of return was reported as negative 6.08%.
When asked about the difference between the original investment and the reported balance, Akshat explained the fund had switched from since-inception reporting to period-over-period performance.
He argued this variation can obscure sustained underperformance.
Market Observers Point to Pantera Connection
After Akshat’s disclosure, social media customers speculated that the fund in query was Pantera Capital’s Early-Stage Token Fund. Pantera, a acknowledged crypto-focused enterprise agency, invests in quite a few early-stage blockchain initiatives.
The agency’s full-spectrum method encompasses personal tokens and early-stage protocols, providing sooner public market liquidity in comparison with conventional fairness investments.
However, Pantera has additionally posted notable wins. In November 2024, the agency announced that its Bitcoin Fund had delivered returns 1,000 instances over greater than a decade.
Recent communications to restricted companions have highlighted a transfer in direction of tokens with robust revenues, which have outperformed riskier belongings.
This controversy reveals the challenges crypto VCs face. The National Venture Capital Association and PitchBook reported that 76% of accomplished acquisitions in early 2025 occurred earlier than a Series B, highlighting the challenges of early-stage exits.
The report additionally pointed to continued investor-friendly deal-making, reflecting rising selectivity and danger aversion amongst VCs.
Maelstrom Pivots to Private Equity and Cash-Flowing Businesses
The restricted accomplice response adopted weeks after Hayes and Akshat introduced Maelstrom Equity Fund I, a brand new buyout personal fairness fund.
This new technique shifts away from speculative tokens and towards worthwhile, off-chain infrastructure firms. According to an October announcement on X, Maelstrom now targets “picks and shovels” companies in crypto.
The intention is to supply clear exits for founders and create acquisition-ready companies for monetary establishments, such as Robinhood and Charles Schwab.
Maelstrom, managed by the household workplace of Arthur Hayes, BitMEX co-founder, emphasizes long-term investing throughout enterprise, liquid, personal fairness, and public markets. Akshat recognized three key points the brand new fund goals to deal with.
- Founders of worthwhile, off-chain companies typically lack clear exit choices and might face multi-year lockups with strategic acquirers.
- Traditional finance entrants wrestle to supply full, ready-to-acquire companies.
- Institutional allocators such as pension funds need to make investments massive sums into crypto however discover poor risk-adjusted returns from large enterprise funds.
The shift towards personal fairness highlights restricted companions’ dissatisfaction with commonplace crypto VC funds, particularly when charges and carry scale back capital throughout downturns.
Maelstrom’s expertise highlights the potential battle between fund scale and efficiency. Whether the transfer to cash-flowing personal fairness will produce higher outcomes is unsure, however heightened scrutiny of VC constructions suggests a defining second for the sector.
The submit Arthur Hayes’ Maelstrom Exec Exposes 44% Loss in Top Crypto VC Bet Even as BTC Doubles appeared first on BeInCrypto.
