The Hidden Cost of Crypto Profits: Why Investors Struggle to File Their Taxes
Digital asset customers are elevating issues about submitting crypto taxes as the amount of on-chain exercise continues to develop.
These points come amid a regulatory shift marked by the adoption of the Crypto-Asset Reporting Framework (CARF) throughout numerous nations. This goals to deal with long-standing gaps in cryptocurrency tax oversight.
IRS Crypto Tax Reporting Requirements within the US
For context, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) treats digital property as property, requiring the reporting of revenue and capital good points from transactions, similar to gross sales, service funds, staking, airdrops, and extra.
It is price noting that merely holding cryptocurrency doesn’t end in a acquire or loss and is therefore not subject to tax. Taxation happens solely when the asset is offered, and money or one other cryptocurrency is obtained. At that time, the good points are thought of “realized,” making a taxable occasion.
“Keep in thoughts that almost all revenue is topic to taxation. Failing to precisely report revenue could end in accrued curiosity and penalties,” the guidelines learn.
For the 2025 tax 12 months, the usual IRS filing deadline is April 15, 2026, until the date falls on a weekend or vacation. Taxpayers could request an extension till October 15, 2026, however this extension applies solely to submitting, not to fee.
Investors Highlight Challenges in Filing Crypto Taxes Amid High-Volume Transactions
While tax guidance is quite clear, execution stays advanced. For traders with high transaction volumes, reconciling exercise throughout centralized exchanges, decentralized exchanges, bridges, liquidity swimming pools, derivatives platforms, and a number of wallets has develop into a major problem.
Errors in transaction classification or value foundation calculation can materially have an effect on reported good points and losses.
“The scary factor is, the burden of proof falls on the taxpayer to refute their low effort place…So in the event you don’t maintain correct information, you would get screwed,” a crypto tax service wrote.
These challenges are most evident amongst high-frequency merchants. In one shared case, an investor often known as “Crypto Safe” reported executing greater than 17,000 transactions throughout a number of blockchains in 2025.
The person added that current tax software program may gather transaction histories however was unable to calculate taxes precisely with out intensive guide evaluate.
“So this 12 months, I’ll merely pay tax on withdrawals on the financial institution, as it’s unimaginable for me to calculate the capital good points on particular person trades,” the post learn.
According to the person, this strategy may end in an estimated overpayment of $15,000 to $ 30,000 in contrast to the precise tax legal responsibility. This state of affairs has drawn consideration from different traders.
“I’ve overpaid yearly since 2012,” one other market watcher added.
Pseudonymous investor “Snooper” shared that submitting crypto taxes, particularly at high transaction volumes, requires superior tax instruments, familiarity with blockchain explorers, and guide information imports. Even with these instruments, the method stays advanced.
The case illustrates that correct compliance more and more requires technical experience past standard accounting practices.
Global Crypto Tax Reporting Enters a New Phase
Meanwhile, 2026 marked a serious shift in international crypto tax regulation throughout many jurisdictions. As of January 1, 2026, 48 jurisdictions have implemented CARF.
This framework requires in-scope service suppliers to gather expanded buyer information, confirm customers’ tax residency, and submit annual stories detailing account balances and transaction exercise to home tax authorities.
That information will then be shared throughout borders underneath current worldwide information-exchange agreements. While the primary computerized worldwide exchanges of this info are scheduled for January 1, 2026, this date serves because the efficient date for jurisdictions to implement the required authorized frameworks and reporting methods.
The initiative contains the UK, Germany, France, Japan, South Korea, Brazil, and many EU nations. The United States, Canada, Australia, and Singapore are scheduled to be a part of later.
Overall, 75 jurisdictions have dedicated to CARF. However, the transfer has attracted substantial criticism from the neighborhood.
“Crypto tax information assortment has begun throughout 48 nations forward of CARF 2027 implementation. Imagine paying tax on crypto the federal government doesn’t even print. This is a down aspect of regulation with all of the superb issues it introduced, Privacy in crypto just isn’t what it used to be,” Brian Rose, Founder and Host of London Real, remarked.
These developments underline a widening hole between regulatory expectations and the sensible capability of traders to comply. While governments are constructing reporting infrastructure, many traders proceed to depend on instruments that wrestle to deal with high-volume, multi-chain exercise.
As tax insurance policies tighten globally, high-frequency crypto customers face rising strain to develop refined compliance workflows or threat inaccurate filings, increased tax prices, and potential disputes with tax authorities.
The publish The Hidden Cost of Crypto Profits: Why Investors Struggle to File Their Taxes appeared first on BeInCrypto.